Monthly Archives: January 2019

Reclaiming Native Space Along the Upper Mississippi—A Photo Essay

Sara Černe (PhD candidate in English, Northwestern

As someone born and raised in Central Europe, I came to the Mississippi River via music: roots rock at first, the blues only later—a backwards trajectory for sure. I associated the river with the vastness of America; with Mark Twain and antebellum steamboats; with African American musical traditions; and with Tina Turner’s cover of “Proud Mary,” of course. Neither Native Americans nor the Upper Mississippi figured in that vision. Writing my dissertation on environmental justice in twentieth- and twenty-first-century literature and culture along the Mississippi at Northwestern University, I have now gone beyond the pop culture understanding of the river, but until recently, the Upper River and Indigenous populations remained conspicuously absent from my research.

In other words, I came to the Humanities Without Walls-sponsored research trip to Minnesota for a collaborative project on Indigenous art and activism in the Mississippi River Valley with very little background in American Indian Studies. I left with a much better understanding of the Dakota and Ojibwe history and present and the importance of the spaces we visited to Indigenous communities native to the area, humbled by the experience.

Wild rice and reflected skies at Lake Itasca, MN—Minnesota’s name is derived from the Dakota phrase ‘Mni Sota Makoce,’ translated as ‘land where the waters reflect the clouds.’

In taking photographs of these places—Lake Itasca in Northern Minnesota; Indian Mounds Park and Wakan Tipi in St. Paul; and the Bdote, the confluence of the Mni Sota Wakpa and the Hahawakpa rivers, the Minnesota and the Mississippi, on the edges of the Twin Cities metro area—I looked for ways in which Native presence, historically as well as presently, is seen, felt, and experienced. Instead of fixating on the myriad ways the US state has worked to disenfranchise and erase Indigenous populations, I wanted to focus on the many acts of perseverance I was witnessing all along the Upper Mississippi.

My first tobacco offering to the Mississippi River at the Headwaters, beginning its 90-day journey to the Gulf of Mexico

The various educators’ and activists’ efforts at regenerating, revitalizing, and reclaiming Native spaces establish firmly Indigenous presents as well as futures. Such actions include cleaning up sacred sites that had been reduced to toxic waste grounds; leading Nibi Walks for water; teaching about the places along the river from an Indigenous point of view using American Indian languages and place names; and marking the areas with Indigenous art.

Grant participants Prof. Jacki Rand (University of Iowa) and Agléška Cohen-Rencountre (University of Minnesota) wading in the Mississippi Headwaters at Itasca, MN.

The Sacred Dish by Duane Goodwin At Indian Mounds Park, St. Paul, MN.

 

In this last category of public art, I would like to highlight two sculptures of Native women—standing rocks, so to speak—that mark their respective spaces as Indigenous even when no one else is around. The first is the 2005 bronze Headwaters—Caretaker Woman by Jeff Savage, a member of the Fond du Lac Band of Lake Superior Chippewa, at Itasca; the second is the 2006 dolomitic limestone The Sacred Dish by Duane “Dewey” Goodwin, a member of the White Earth Band of Ojibwe, in Indian Mounds Park.

Emphasizing Native American feminine cosmology in which women are seen as the custodians of water and earth, the two sculptures pay tribute to the ancestors and speak to the importance of traditional knowledge and practices for the health of the planet and future generations. They also serve as beautiful and unequivocal reminders that these places I was lucky enough to visit are Indigenous—yesterday, today, and tomorrow.

Headwaters—Caretaker Woman by Jeff Savage in Itasca State Park, MN .

Nathan Phillips: Omaha Elder for All Americans

Of all the groups in the modern world Indians are best able to cope with the modern situation. To the non-Indian world, it does not appear that Indians are capable of anything. The flexibility of the tribal viewpoint enables Indians to meet devastating situations and survive. But this flexibility is seen as incompetency, so that as the non-Indian struggles in solitude and despair, he curses the Indian for not coveting the same disaster.” —Vine Deloria, Jr. We Talk, You Listen

Nathan Phillips, Omaha Nation elder and Vietnam-era veteran, has become the most recent face of indigenous resistance in the present-day United States. As reported in multiple news outlets, Phillips was harassed by a group of white high school students wearing MAGA hats, an incident that was caught on video and has since gone viral on the internet.

Nathan Phillips, honoring his fellow soldiers at Arlington National Cemetery.

Phillips has been lauded as a hero and his recent experience, an example of “discourse in Trump’s America,” but what is also true is that he has been an activist in the arena of tribal sovereignty for a very long time. Phillips is former director of the Native Youth Alliance, served as a Water Protector in the DAPL standoff, and visits Arlington National Cemetery every Veterans Day to honor his fallen comrades.

He is in many ways the embodiment of the “tribal viewpoint” Standing Rock scholar and activist Vine Deloria, Jr. spoke of in his 1970 book, We Talk, You Listen. When faced with adversity, Deloria argued, the Native person invested with a tribal viewpoint not only stands up as a protector of land and community, but also as a teacher and healer, exposing the dominant society’s own “solitude and despair.”

When viewed against Mr. Phillips’ steadfast singing in the face of ridicule and the threat of physical violence, the students’ smirking and chanting (“Build that wall, build that wall”) is laid bare as a kind of whistling in the dark. Adrift in a world where they have no real roots or beliefs, these young people vent their hatred on those who hew to a deeper sense of belonging to this earth and its peoples. The ridiculousness of chanting about immigration to a Native American veteran seems to have been lost on these high schoolers and their would-be defenders, who here and there in comments sections of news reports claim the footage has been edited to put the young people in the worst possible light. In fact, expanded video clips of the scene show that Mr. Phillips had taken up his drum and began walking toward the young people and another group they had clashed with. He began to sing, as he said, “to sing a song to hopefully change something.”

  “as the non-Indian struggles in solitude and despair, he curses the Indian for not coveting the same disaster.”

Vine Deloria, Jr.

For his part, Nathan Phillips remains philosophical about the incident. Speaking to a reporter from the Washington Post, Phillips said, “That energy could be turned into feeding the people, cleaning up our communities and figuring out what else we can do, . . . We need the young people to be doing that instead of saying, ‘These guys are our enemies.’ ”

As Vine Deloria, Jr. said, “To the non-Indian world, it does not appear that Indians are capable of anything.” Yet here is Nathan Phillips standing up against bigotry alone, even as the senators, congressmen, and judges of the president’s party disappear into the woodwork of “plausible deniability” and a silent tolerance for hatred that has only served to encourage the misguidedness of young people like those Kentucky students who sought to belittle a man from whom they could learn a great deal.

 

Sources:

https://www.indianz.com/News/2019/01/19/video-omaha-elder-taunted-by-maga-youth.asp

https://www.washingtonpost.com/nation/2019/01/20/it-was-getting-ugly-native-american-drummer-speaks-maga-hat-wearing-teens-who-surrounded-him/?utm_term=.06332b5b4e80

https://www.washingtonpost.com/local/social-issues/picture-of-the-conflict-on-the-mall-comes-into-clearer-focus/2019/01/20/c078f092-1ceb-11e9-9145-3f74070bbdb9_story.html?utm_term=.3b5030be0dc5

https://www.washingtonpost.com/national-security/2019/01/23/nathan-phillips-man-standoff-with-covington-teens-faces-scrutiny-his-military-past/?utm_term=.fafe8aaaec8c

“Wakpa Thanka kin”

By Samantha Maijhor (PhD Candidate in English, University of Minnesota)

wakpá ipȟá ed
wakpá tȟáŋka kči napéwéčhiyuze
uŋkičhiksuyapi
wakpá tȟaŋka ahdádha wóčhekiye hóyewaye
aŋpétu waŋ ed wóčhekiyeg hená ahdíyuweǧa kte
óhŋni mní kiŋ hdi
óhŋni mní kiŋ hdi kte

wakáŋ thípi ed
théhaŋ okátȟa kiŋ maúŋnipi
théhaŋ osní kiŋ maúŋnipi
______ kiŋ uŋkakidowaŋpi ičinš uŋči makȟa kiŋ wa akaȟpe
______ čhaze kiŋ uŋkeypai šni kiŋhaŋ wahiŋhe šni
wanaphobyapig uŋpi k’a iǧuǧa oȟdoka kiŋ ihagyapi
óhŋni wičhaȟpi kiŋ mani ohna thaniŋiŋ
waniyetu k’a bdoketu kiŋ nuphiŋ mniowe kiŋ čhaǧa šni
mni wičhóni

bdote ed
wakpá tȟaŋka kiŋ k’a mnisota kči ečhipha čha hetu
watapheta waŋ iŋkpatakiya wabdake
dečed Dakȟóta oyáte kiŋ thuŋpi eyapi
Omaka 1862 heéhaŋ hed Dakȟóta oyáte kiŋ wičhakaksapi
k’a hehaŋ óta wyazaŋpi k’a t’api
uŋkaŋ watapheta waŋ wakpá tȟáŋka ogna awíchaipi
waŋna bdote ed Dakȟóta oyáteg hdipi
mni s’e óhŋni Dakȟod hdipi kte

Táku uŋkákupi kta ke?
Táku mní kiŋ aku kta he?

 

 

1. At the headwaters, I shook hands with the Mississippi, we remember(ed) each other, I sent a prayer along the river, one day the words will return, the water always returns

2. At Wakan Tipi, we walked in the heat for a long time / we walked in the cold for a long time, we sang to ___ because the earth was blanketed with snow / we didn’t say _______’s name when there was no snow, they used explosives and destroyed the cave, the railroad men came here and destroyed the womb, the stars still reflect in the water, in both winter and summer the spring does not freeze, the water lives/water is life

3. At Bdote / It is at that place where the Mississippi and the Minnesota rivers meet / I saw a steamboat go upstream / they say the Dakota people emerged here / Back in 1862 the Dakota people were jailed there / and at that time many were sick and died / and then a steamboat took them away on the Mississippi river / now the Dakota people have returned to Bdote / like water the Dakota people will always return here.

4. What will we bring when we come back here?
5. What will the water bring back?

Humanities Without Walls: The Upper Mississippi

By Sara Černe, Agléška R. Cohen-Rencountre, Bonnie Etherington, Andrew Freiman, and Samantha Majhor.

In September 2018, the authors of this post traveled to various locations along the Upper Mississippi in Minnesota as graduate participants with a 2018-2020 multi-institutional, interdisciplinary Humanities Without Walls project. Entitled “Indigenous Art and Activism in Changing Climates: The Mississippi River Valley, Colonialism, and Environmental Change,” the project is funded by the Andrew Mellon Foundation. We were joined by faculty: Kelly Wisecup (Project Leader & PI, Northwestern), Vicente Diaz (Co-PI, U of Minnesota), Christopher Pexa (Project Coordinator, U of Minnesota), Jacki Thompson Rand (U of Iowa), Phillip Round (U of Iowa), and Caroline Wigginton (U of Mississippi). Other faculty participants are Doug Kiel (Northwestern), Robert Michael Morrissey (U of Illinois Urbana-Champaign), and Project Advisors Margaret Pearce (U of Maine) and Robbie Ethridge (U of Mississippi). Over the next two years we will all also travel to Chicago and to Mississippi as we develop our collaborative research. After the trip to the upper reaches of the river valley, we graduate student participants compiled our reflections. We combine the critical with the creative, and include visual responses with poetic, essay, and other textual reflections.

Jim Rock (Dakota) explains the significance of caves along the Mississippi in the Twin Cities. Jim is Planetarium Projects Director at the University of Minnesota, Duluth.

 

In the next few issues of The Repatriation Files, we share our responses to our initial encounters with the Mississippi.

 

In September 2018, the authors of this post traveled to various locations along the Upper Mississippi in Minnesota as graduate participants with a 2018-2020 multi-institutional, interdisciplinary Humanities Without Walls project. Entitled “Indigenous Art and Activism in Changing Climates: The Mississippi River Valley, Colonialism, and Environmental Change,” the project is funded by the Andrew Mellon Foundation. We were joined by faculty: Kelly Wisecup (Project Leader & PI, Northwestern), Vicente Diaz (Co-PI, U of Minnesota), Christopher Pexa (Project Coordinator, U of Minnesota), Jacki Thompson Rand (U of Iowa), Phillip Round (U of Iowa), and Caroline Wigginton (U of Mississippi). Other faculty participants are Doug Kiel (Northwestern), Robert Michael Morrissey (U of Illinois Urbana-Champaign), and Project Advisors Margaret Pearce (U of Maine) and Robbie Ethridge (U of Mississippi). Over the next two years we will all also travel to Chicago and to Mississippi as we develop our collaborative research. After the trip to the upper reaches of the river valley, we graduate student participants compiled our reflections. We combine the critical with the creative, and include visual responses with poetic, essay, and other textual reflections.

Shutdown in Indian Country

As the President and Congress spar over funding for a border wall as a condition for re-opening the Federal Government, Native citizens across Indian Country are experiencing major disruptions to their daily lives.

Indian Country Today reports, “Sen. Tina Smith, D-Minnesota, said on MSNBC this morning that the chairman of the Bois Forte Band of Chippewa told her that tribal police are not being paid because of the shutdown. Funding for tribal law enforcement contracts are on hold during the shutdown.”

It is a similar story for those Native communities who rely on the Indian Health Service (IHS), a federal entity whose services are often guaranteed by treaty. A recent report in the New York Times estimates that for one tribe of the Chippewa in the Upper Peninsula of Michigan, the shutdown is costing “about $100,000, every day,  . . . federal money that does not arrive to keep health clinics staffed, food pantry shelves full and employees paid.” Some 1.9 million Native people are being affected.

The same is true of the Bureau of Indian Affairs (BIA). Writing to officials in Washington D.C., Colville Business Council Chair Rodney Cawston, in recent article in the Tribal Tribune of Nespelem, WA, argues that the shutdown has had “a disproportionate impact to tribes’ related to land management, health services and other social service programs.” Cawston believes “the impact to the tribal timber industry alone is resulting in a tribal loss of approximately $400,000 weekly and the impact to federal direct and indirect support costs is resulting in a loss of $1.5 million weekly.”

“The trust responsibility that underlies the functions that the IHS and BIA serve makes them much different from National parks and traditional land management functions of the Department of Interior.”

Rodney Cawston

A visit to the IHS website this week displays the stark reality of the shutdown for indigenous communities.

“Dear Tribal Leader,” the message reads, “there will be no funding available from the HIS until such time as appropriations are enacted and available for such purposes. We acknowledge that this circumstance may result in insufficient funds to carry out the terms of the agreement (the Self-Determination and Education Assistance Act) and that the program may cease to operate.”

Coming on the heels of a year-long assault on Native land by the Department of Interior and the Trump administration, the shutdown of the federal government is yet another blow to tribal sovereignty and yet another example of promises unkept.

As Kevin Washburn, who served as the assistant secretary for Indian Affairs under President Barack Obama, explained to a reporter from the New York Times, during a shutdown, “Indian Country stops moving forward . . . and starts moving backward.”

It is time this administration started honoring its trust obligations to Native people.

Further Reading

http://www.tribaltribune.com/news/article_92a5690a-12b6-11e9-aafc-57f1d70299a4.html

https://newsmaven.io/indiancountrytoday/news/president-to-make-case-for-border-wall-on-national-tv-tonight-2KDXu9vWn0KmPXohJq9nWQ/?fbclid=IwAR3y9l7pPbM19ZeZAhXlnKQ_iE2b1r5Rl8–0iheGbqgD9TTtJYuYyX45Zs